Blogcontent strategy
Content pillars from what your audience actually discusses
Content pillars are the 3 to 5 themes you post about again and again. Here's how to pick them from real threads and comments, with counts and links.
Khalid SayfullahFounder, Doddlesoft5 min read
Short answer
Content pillars are the three to five themes an account posts about again and again, so people know what to expect and why to follow. Instead of picking them in a brainstorm, read a month of your audience's subreddit and the comments on a few top videos in your niche, group what they talk about with a count and a link for each theme, and turn the biggest three to five groups into pillars.
Find content pillars in your audience's own conversations
- 1Connect ScrollhoundIn Claude, open Customize, then Connectors, add a custom connector named Scrollhound with the URL https://api.scrollhound.com/mcp, and sign in with your email.
- 2Read the subredditAsk Claude for the subreddit's top posts this month, then the comments on the busiest thread.
- 3Read the video commentsAsk for the top 50 comments on two or three of the most viewed videos in your niche on TikTok or YouTube.
- 4Group and countAsk Claude to group everything into themes, count the posts and comments in each, and keep a link for every one.
- 5Pick the pillarsKeep the three to five biggest themes that fit what you sell or want to be known for, and turn each into a pillar with a few post ideas.
Most content pillar guides tell you to brainstorm: list what your brand stands for, pick a few themes, done. The weak point is that the themes come from you. Pillars work better when they come from what your audience already talks about, because then every pillar has demand behind it from day one.
That takes reading, not guessing. Here’s the method on one real audience: people who do social media for a living.
The prompt
I'm planning content pillars for an account aimed at <your audience>.1. Read the top 40 posts this month in r/<subreddit>, and the comments on the post with the most comments.2. Read the top 50 comments on each of these videos: <2 or 3 links>.3. Group everything into themes. For each theme give the number of posts and comments in it, two exact quotes with links, and the questions people asked.4. Rank the themes by size, then suggest 3 to 5 content pillars, each with 3 post ideas taken from a real question or complaint.Note any theme that comes mostly from one author.The reading part is the voice-of-customer recipe; this prompt adds the grouping and the pillars on top.
What came back
Run on 3 Nov 2026 on r/socialmedia, top posts this month, plus the comments on two of the most viewed TikToks for “social media marketing tips”. We read 37 posts, 36 comments on the subreddit’s busiest thread and 100 TikTok comments.
The 37 posts sorted into five themes, with seven left over:
| Theme | Posts | Example |
|---|---|---|
| Growing small accounts: cadence, virality, the algorithm | 8 | Is posting every day really necessary to grow on Instagram? (53 comments) |
| How the platforms are changing | 7 | What social media trend are you noticing right now? (126 points, the month’s top post) |
| Client work: scope, approvals, pay | 6 | My client was paying for 20 hours and using 9 (82 points) |
| Tools and AI in the workflow | 6 | Claude Pro for Social Media Managers (23 comments) |
| Where ideas and trends come from | 3 | How do you guys find trending sounds, edits and content ideas? |
A caution the counts alone would hide: all six client-work posts are by one author, and three of the eight growth posts are by another. Those themes are still real (the client posts got 8 to 82 points each), but they’re louder than the number of people behind them. That’s why the prompt asks Claude to flag single-author themes.
What the comments added
The post titles say what people talk about. The comments say what they want.
On the busiest growth thread, Hot take: going viral once is one of the worst things that can happen to a small account (119 comments), the most upvoted reply (16 points) ends: “Post the content you want to be know for lol.” Another commenter went viral with the wrong crowd and started over: “Thousands of followers from outside my ideal audience and it TANKED my engagement and distribution.” A third described keeping “like 70% of what regulars respond to” and using the rest for experiments. That thread is the case for pillars, written by the audience.
The TikTok comments brought out a theme the subreddit barely touched: money. On Ellie Frazier’s video about creators in a slump (96.8K views), 6 of the top 50 comments asked how she earns, and the most liked comment (80 likes) was “I have 265k here and 121k on ig and I can’t seem to monetize”. Two more commenters were stuck on their niche, including “my niche is everything 😭”. On a video about turning Google’s “People also ask” into a year of content (233K views, 19.9K saves), 10 of 50 comments said the method was basic SEO, and one asked what the video didn’t answer: “so do we stay on 1 topic per month, or do we rotate the topics?”
From themes to pillars
Merging the money questions into client work, and keeping the order by size, gives five pillars for an account aimed at social media managers:
- Growing small accounts. Post ideas: how often to post when you’re small (the daily-posting thread had 53 comments); what happened when someone went viral with the wrong audience; the 70/30 split between what regulars want and experiments.
- What’s changing on the platforms. Post ideas: the trends people say they’re noticing; what Facebook’s two-link-posts-a-month limit means for pages; whether Threads is worth the effort.
- Running the business: clients, scope and pay. Post ideas: how to raise scope creep with a client; who covers Black Friday weekend; and, from TikTok, how creators with big followings still struggle to monetize.
- Tools and AI that save real time. Post ideas: which Claude connectors social media managers use; whether scheduling tools actually save time; what an AI agent can and can’t take off your plate.
- Where ideas come from. Post ideas: how to find trends without scrolling for hours; using your audience’s questions as a content calendar; and the “rotate the topics?” question nobody answered.
Every idea on that list points back to a thread or a comment, so when a client asks why you chose these pillars, you can show them.
Two things to keep in mind. The pillars have to fit what you sell or want to be known for; if nobody you serve cares about Threads, drop that idea even if the thread was busy. And this was one subreddit and two videos on one day. For pillars you’ll use for a quarter, read two or three subreddits and three to five videos, or run the read weekly for a month.
Keep the pillars honest
Audiences shift. The weekly niche brief recipe reads your niche’s top posts every Monday through a Claude scheduled task (on paid Claude plans) and sends a digest with links, which is an easy way to see whether a pillar is getting louder or quieter. The setup is written up here. There are no real-time alerts; it’s a weekly read.
Other ways to do this
- A brainstorm and your analytics. Your own top posts tell you what already works for your audience. Use them alongside this method: analytics show what people watched, threads and comments show what they’re asking for next.
- Reading by hand. Everything above is public. Scrolling a subreddit and a few comment sections for an hour gets you most of the way; you’ll have impressions rather than counts and links.
- Keyword tools such as AnswerThePublic show what people type into Google. They’re good for search content and miss the stories and complaints that come out in comments.
To run the prompt, set up Scrollhound in Claude or ChatGPT. It only reads public posts and comments, never posts or follows, and 100 reads are free for your first 7 days, with no card. For the Reddit side in more depth, see Reddit customer research with Claude.
Questions
What are content pillars?
The three to five themes an account keeps coming back to. Every post fits one of them, which makes the account easy to recognise and easier to plan.
How many content pillars should I have?
Three to five is the usual range. Fewer and the feed gets repetitive; more and it stops being clear what the account is about.
What are some content pillar examples?
For an account aimed at social media managers, the run in this post gave five: client work and pay, growing small accounts, platform changes, tools and AI, and where ideas come from.
How often should I revisit my pillars?
Every quarter is enough for most accounts. Run the same read again and see whether the counts have moved.
Can I do this without Reddit?
Yes. Comments on YouTube videos, TikToks, Reels or LinkedIn posts in your niche work too. Reddit helps because people write longer and ask more direct questions there.