Skip to content
scrollhound

Blogyoutube

YouTube video ideas your audience already asked for

Find YouTube video ideas in the comments under the top videos in your niche: group the questions people repeat, count them, and keep a link to each. A real run on three videos.

Khalid SayfullahFounder, Doddlesoft6 min read

Short answer

Read the comments under the most watched videos in your niche, skip the thanks and check-ins, and group the questions people repeat. Each group is a video idea, and its count tells you how many people want it. With Scrollhound connected, Claude or ChatGPT reads the comments on several videos at once and gives you the list with counts, exact quotes and links.

Find YouTube video ideas in comments

  1. 1Pick the videosFind three to five of the most watched videos in your niche from the last year. In Claude with Scrollhound, ask it to search YouTube for your topic sorted by views.
  2. 2Read the commentsRead the top 50 to 100 comments on each, plus the newest comments that mention your niche's key word, where the fresh questions are.
  3. 3Group and countDrop thanks, check-ins and self-promotion. Group the questions that ask the same thing, count each group and keep one exact quote and the video link.
  4. 4Check what existsBefore you film, check whether the channels in your niche already answered the top questions. The ones nobody answered well go first.

Most lists of YouTube video ideas are the same 50 formats: day in the life, a challenge, a tutorial, a Q&A. They’re fine if you have no audience yet. If you do, or if you’re working in a niche someone else already serves, there’s a better list, and the audience wrote it for you. It’s in the comments under the videos that already did well.

People don’t comment “please make a video about X” very often. They ask questions they still have after watching, push back on advice that doesn’t fit them, and tell stories about what happened when they tried it. Each of those is a video idea, and when ten people ask the same thing, it’s a video with demand.

The method

  1. Pick three to five of the most watched videos in your niche from the last year. Different channels, so you hear more than one audience.
  2. Read the top comments and the newest ones. On a big video, Top is mostly thanks. The fresh questions sit lower down, so add a word search for your niche’s main term, newest first.
  3. Skip the noise. Thanks, “who’s here in 2026”, self-promotion, and comments that read like ads for a tool.
  4. Group and count. Put the questions that ask the same thing together. Keep one quote, the handle and the video link for each group.
  5. Check what’s already been made. If a channel in your niche already answered the top question well, move to the next one.

Done by hand on three videos, that’s an afternoon of scrolling and copying. In Claude or ChatGPT with Scrollhound connected, it’s one prompt.

The prompt

Search YouTube for "<your topic>" from the last year, sorted by views, and pick the 3 most watched
videos from different channels.
For each, read the top 50 comments, plus the newest comments that mention "<your key word>".
Skip thanks, check-ins and self-promotion.
Group the questions, complaints and stories people repeat into video ideas. For each idea give:
how many comments raise it, which videos they're on, one exact quote with the handle and date,
and the video link. Rank them by count. Say how many comments you read in total.

A real run: three videos about growing as a creator

Run on 3 Nov 2026. We searched YouTube for “social media manager tips” from the last year, sorted by views, and read the comments on three of the top results:

That’s about 180 comments (two turned up in both Millie reads). Most of the top ones on the first two videos were thanks, and a few on Joanna Wiebe’s video read like promotions for AI tools, so we left those out. Here’s what was left, ranked by how many comments raised it:

Video idea Comments Where In their words
Volume or quality when you’re one person 7 GaryVee “There is still room for quality content in small batches. Serve your niche exceedingly well.” (@MarkSchaefer, 153 likes)
One niche or several, when you have many interests 6 Millie “Quick question, can you niche in multiple areas?” (@JVarMartin)
Should your brand stay on social media if people are leaving? 5 GaryVee “I’ve deleted a good majority of my social accounts and I’m happy.” (@Elizabeth_Childs, 152 likes)
A separate account for each niche or platform? 4 Millie “Any opinions on creating a new instagram page for your niche?” (@TheShelbyLeeper)
What “niche down” means, with examples 3 Millie “What is ‘niche down”?” (@jenmdawg)
Why you went viral once and then nothing 2 GaryVee “viral posts don’t translate into multiple viral posts, followers, or success” (@seaweedsnacks)
Learning from creators in your niche without copying them 2 Millie “how do i go about this to make mine unique but in the same pathways as theirs” (@momentswithlumi.e2081)
A channel critique: thumbnail, bio, titles 1 thread Joanna Wiebe A new creator asked for encouragement (173 likes); the first reply was “Your thumbnail is the problem”

A few notes on reading this:

The top idea came from pushback, not a question. GaryVee’s video talks about posting at huge volume. Seven of the top 50 comments push back on it, several pointing out that he has a team: “you should say, you have a team, that does the back work” (@innerpower1046). A video that takes the other side, for the solo creator or the one-person social team, already has an audience in those replies.

The niche questions are at least four videos. On Millie’s video, “niche” brought up 16 questions, but they ask different things: what it means, whether you can have several, whether each needs its own account, and how to study others without copying. One “how to pick a niche” video would answer none of them well.

Small counts are still worth noting. The channel-critique thread is one comment, but its replies did the critique for free (“Change the titles of your videos make them more catchy. Change the thumbnails.”). That’s a format, not just a topic.

This is a sample of about 180 comments, not a survey. It tells you what to test first and gives you the words to put in the title. It doesn’t tell you how many people will search for it.

Check what’s already been made

Before filming the top idea, look at what the bigger channels in your niche already posted on it. The competitor channel teardown recipe lists a channel’s recent uploads with views and reads the transcripts of the most viewed ones, so you can see whether “volume vs quality for a solo creator” has been done, and how well.

For one video at a time, or to search a comment section for a single word, see how to search YouTube comments. The full prompt for other platforms is the comment mining recipe: the same method works on TikToks, Instagram Reels and Reddit threads.

Where other tools fit better

  • YouTube Studio’s Research tab shows what your viewers and YouTube as a whole are searching for. Use it to check demand for the ideas on your list.
  • vidIQ and TubeBuddy score keywords and suggest titles. They’re better at “how many search for this” than at “what exactly are people confused about”.
  • A video idea list or generator is still useful when you’re starting a channel from zero and have no niche to read yet.

Comments give you the idea and the wording. A search tool tells you the size. Used together, you film the videos people asked for and title them the way people asked.

Scrollhound only reads public comments. It doesn’t post, like or reply, and it doesn’t need your YouTube login. It works as a connector in Claude on any plan and in ChatGPT on Pro, Business, Enterprise and Edu. 100 reads are free for your first 7 days, no card needed.

Questions

Why use comments instead of a video idea generator?

A generator guesses what might interest people. A comment is someone asking for it, in their own words, often with the reason. Those words also make good titles and hooks.

How many comments do I need to read?

Fifty to a hundred top comments on each of three to five videos is enough to see the patterns. Add a word search, newest first, because the top comments on a popular video are mostly thanks.

Should I read my competitors' comments or my own?

Both. Your own comments tell you what your viewers want next. Competitors' comments show what their viewers asked and didn't get, which is often the easier video to win.

Does this replace keyword tools like vidIQ or TubeBuddy?

No. Keyword tools and YouTube Studio's Research tab show how many people search a topic. Comments show what they're confused about and how they say it. Use comments for the idea and the wording, and a search tool to check demand.

Let your AI read the whole conversation.

Try a tool right now, or sign up and get your first 100 reads for $0.

Start for $0 Try a free tool

No credit card · Read-only · Never asks for your social logins