Skip to content
scrollhound

Blogreddit

How to validate a product idea with Reddit comments, using Claude or ChatGPT

Check demand for an idea on Reddit with Claude or ChatGPT: pain, workarounds, what people pay for and who says it isn't worth it. A real run, 5 Nov 2026.

Khalid SayfullahFounder, Doddlesoft4 min read

Short answer

Search the subreddits where your buyers talk for the problem, not your product, sorted by top posts of the past year. Then have Claude or ChatGPT read the busiest threads with their comments and sort what people say into five signals: the pain, what they do about it today, what they already pay for, what they wish existed, and who says the problem isn't worth solving. With Scrollhound connected that's one prompt, and every quote links to its comment.

Validate a product idea with Reddit comments

  1. 1Write the problem, not the productDescribe the job your idea does in the words a buyer would use, for example 'turning podcast episodes into clips'. Searching for your product name finds nothing yet.
  2. 2Search inside the right subredditsPick two to four subreddits where the buyers talk and search each one for the problem, sorted by top posts of the past year.
  3. 3Read the busiest threads in fullHave Claude read the three to five threads with the most comments, up to 100 comments each. The evidence is in the comments, not the titles.
  4. 4Sort the comments into five signalsAsk for pain, workarounds, what people pay for today, what they wish existed, and objections, each with an exact quote and its link.
  5. 5Decide what the gap isLook for the part of the problem that people say no current tool solves. That gap, not the whole category, is the idea worth testing.

Most idea validation on Reddit goes wrong the same way: someone searches for their product, finds a few posts that agree with them, and stops. The useful evidence is in the comments, where people say what they tried, what they pay for, and why they gave up. A busy thread has a hundred of those, and that’s the reading Claude or ChatGPT can do for you once it can see the threads.

The prompt

I'm validating an idea: <one sentence, in the buyer's words>.
Search r/<subreddit> and r/<subreddit> for "<the problem>", top posts of the past year. Read the
five threads with the most comments, up to 100 comments each. Sort what people say into:
1. the pain, and what it costs them (time or money),
2. what they do about it today,
3. the tools they pay for, with prices if they mention them,
4. what they wish existed,
5. people who say the problem isn't worth solving.
Give an exact quote and its link for each point. Then tell me which part of the problem nobody
says is solved.

A real run: a podcast clipping tool

Say the idea is a tool that turns long podcast episodes into short clips. On 5 November 2026 we searched r/podcasting for “clips tool”, top posts of the past year, and read the two busiest threads that came back:

The search itself was a signal. Of its 25 results, several were people comparing tools: “Descript or better alternatives”, “I tested almost all OpusClip alternatives”, “What are the best Submagic alternatives?”. People shop for this.

Here’s what the comments said, sorted into the five signals:

Signal Exact quote Thread
Pain “The post-production repurposing is slowly draining my will to live.” 4+ hours
Pain “the AI keeps picking the most boring parts of the conversation” 4+ hours
Workaround “I keep a notepad open while recording and jot the timestamp any time the conversation genuinely lands” 4+ hours
Workaround “I just feed chat gpt my JSON transcript, ask for the best parts, and go from there.” 4+ hours
Already paying “I use opusclip. Worth the 15 bucks a month” 4+ hours
Already paying Reelify: “$60, no subscription, and it works really well.” 4+ hours
Unsolved “The multi-speaker vertical reframing problem is legitimately unsolved at the consumer level.” All kind of suck
Unsolved “the starting and ending is still a little abrupt” All kind of suck
Not worth it “I stopped doing it. Nothing happened to my downloads.” 4+ hours
Not worth it “I’ve never heard of anyone saying it works to find new engaged listeners.” 4+ hours

Two more things only the comments showed:

  • The market is crowded with builders. In the 41 comments we read on the second thread, at least ten people said they had built or were building a clipping tool, several with a link. The original poster even complained that “nearly every “best clipping tool 2026” list is owned by a clipping tool.”
  • The demand is real but split. Plenty of people pay, and plenty of others said they don’t make clips at all and haven’t missed them.

What we’d conclude. “An AI clipping tool” is a crowded idea with a known price point, about $15 a month. Commenters kept naming the same unsolved parts: framing two speakers in a vertical clip, cuts that start and end mid-thought, and picking moments that are actually good rather than loud. An idea aimed at one of those, sold to people who already pay for Opus Clip, is worth testing. Another general clipper probably isn’t. Every quote above links back to the comment, so you can show your reasoning to a cofounder or an investor.

Make the read wider

One subreddit is one crowd. Before you decide, check the same problem in a couple more places:

  • Another subreddit with a different kind of buyer: here r/socialmedia, where people who run accounts for clients talk.
  • YouTube comments on a review of the leading tool. People list what’s missing in reply to reviews. See how to search YouTube comments.
  • Hacker News if the buyer is technical. Launch threads there are full of objections.
  • Subreddit rules before you post anything to ask about your idea. Use the subreddit rules check first.

Reading the signals honestly

  • Count what you read, not the market. “Ten of 41 comments” describes this thread, not all podcasters. Reddit skews toward people who like to discuss and complain.
  • Weigh spending over sympathy. An upvote costs nothing. “Worth the 15 bucks a month” is a price someone actually pays.
  • Look for the skeptics on purpose. The prompt asks for them because the comments that say “I stopped doing it” are the ones that save you months.
  • Open a few links. Every quote should be in the comment it links to, word for word.

The same method works for customer research once you have a product: see Reddit customer research with Claude and the voice-of-customer recipe. If you haven’t connected Scrollhound yet, setup takes two minutes, and new accounts get 100 free reads for the first 7 days, with no card. A Reddit thread with its comments is 1 read.

Questions

Can Reddit prove there's a market for my idea?

No. Reddit shows that a problem exists, how people describe it and what they already pay for. It doesn't tell you how many buyers there are. Treat it as the evidence that decides what to test next, then test with real people.

Do I need a Reddit account or the Reddit API?

No. Scrollhound reads public posts and comments without a Reddit login, and it never posts, votes or messages anyone. You add it to Claude or ChatGPT as a connector.

How many threads are enough?

Read until new threads stop adding new pains or new tools. For a narrow problem that's often five to ten threads across two or three subreddits.

What's the strongest demand signal in a thread?

Money and time already being spent: people naming the tool they pay for, the price, or the hours a week the problem costs them. Upvotes on the post matter less than what the comments say people actually do.

Should I post in the subreddit to ask about my idea?

Read first. Many subreddits remove posts that look like market research or promotion, so check the rules before you post, and never present a survey as a casual question.

Let your AI read the whole conversation.

Try a tool right now, or sign up and get your first 100 reads for $0.

Start for $0 Try a free tool

No credit card · Read-only · Never asks for your social logins