Skip to content
scrollhound

Blogcustomer research

Voice of customer research from public comments: the Halo strategy, step by step

Find your market's pains, fears and desires in their own words from Reddit, YouTube and TikTok comments, with Claude or ChatGPT. A real run on protein powder, 6 Nov 2026.

Khalid SayfullahFounder, Doddlesoft4 min read

Short answer

Pick the one keyword your buyers type, read the subreddits where they discuss buying (not general ones), the most discussed threads in full, and the comments under the most-watched YouTube and TikTok reviews. Sort exact quotes into pains (what hurts now), fears (what they worry is true) and desires (what they want instead), and mark the quotes from people who say they bought. With Scrollhound connected to Claude or ChatGPT, that's one prompt, and every quote keeps its link.

Run voice of customer research with the Halo strategy

  1. 1Choose the one keywordUse the word most buyers would type for what you sell, like 'protein powder', not your category's industry name.
  2. 2Go where buyers talkFind the subreddits where people discuss buying it. A search across all of Reddit returns jokes and recipes, not buyers.
  3. 3Read the busiest threads in fullSort the subreddits' posts of the past year by most comments and read the top four with up to 200 comments each, then the comments on the most-watched YouTube and TikTok reviews.
  4. 4Sort quotes into pains, fears and desiresGroup exact quotes by theme under each heading, count how often each came up, and mark the quotes from people who say they bought, use, switched or cancelled.
  5. 5Turn it into copyPull out the phrases worth using word for word, the objections to answer, and a headline for each strong pain, fear or desire.

Most AI-written copy sounds the same because it’s written from the model’s average, not from the market. The fix isn’t a better prompt. It’s giving the assistant what your buyers actually said, and the cheapest place to get that is public comments: Reddit threads, and the comment sections under the reviews people watch before they buy.

Sabri Suby calls this the Halo strategy: forage through forums for the most emotionally charged comments and sort them into pains, fears and desires. It works. It’s also hours of scrolling, which is the part Claude or ChatGPT can do once it can read the threads.

The prompt

This is the Halo strategy recipe. Paste it into Claude or ChatGPT with Scrollhound connected:

Use Scrollhound to run the Halo strategy for "<keyword>": find the pains, fears and desires of the
people who buy it, in their own words.
1. Reddit: work inside the subreddits where buyers talk, not general ones where it's a joke
(use r/<subreddit> if I named one, otherwise find the 3 best). Search posts of the past year by
most comments and read the 4 most discussed threads with up to 200 comments each.
2. YouTube: search "<keyword> review" by views and read the top comments on the 2 most-watched.
3. TikTok: search "<keyword>" and read the comments on the 2 most-played.
Sort what you find into Pains, Fears and Desires: themes from most to least mentioned, each with
a count, two exact quotes and links. Mark a quote BUYER when the person says they bought, use,
switched from or cancelled something. Then give me the market's own words, the objections, and
three headline ideas.

A real run: protein powder

Protein powder is Sabri’s own example keyword, so we used it on 6 November 2026.

First, the mistake the recipe avoids. A comment search across all of Reddit for “protein powder” over the past year returned 40 comments, and most were jokes: “Eating hands like it’s protein powder”, recipes for baked oats, a Skyrim meme. Buyers don’t talk in r/meirl. Inside r/Supplements, sorting the year’s posts by comments, the top thread was “Protein powder is such a ripoff these days. Anything good and reasonable?” with 177 comments. Reading 60 of them gave more than the 40 scattered comments did.

Pains

  • Price. “$55-$60+ for all these brands for 2lb is criminal.” BUYER: the same person says “I used to buy ON”. (thread)
  • “I just left Costco, the 5.5lb optimum bag is now $75. Insane, used to be $50.” BUYER (thread)
  • Someone who says they’ve been in the industry 20 years expects it to get worse: “Expect companies to turn 2lb tubs to turn to 1lb and 5lb tubs to 3lbs to get past sticker price shock.” (thread)

Fears

  • Contamination. “Double whammy is the Consumer Reports drop on even some organic protein powders being highly contaminated with lead.” (thread)
  • Cheap means fake. “I would be extremely careful with anyone selling you dramatically cheaper products, they likely do not have the levels of protein they are advertising.” (thread)

Desires

  • Low effort. “The point of protein powder is a 0 effort quick and decently cheap extra protein source to supplement whole food intake that is easy to get down.” BUYER (thread)
  • Tastes of nothing. “Both are relatively cheap, completely neutral tasting and smooth/easy to mix.” BUYER: they buy on subscription. (thread)
  • Proof they can check. “They also publish CoA certificates if you want to verify the composition.” (thread)

On YouTube, the comments under a 1.9M-view ingredient review of one brand (video) said the same thing from the other side. Most were requests for more reviews (“Please do videos for good products too so that we know what to buy”): people want someone to check the label for them.

What it gives a copywriter

Three headlines fall straight out of it, each answering one theme: price per gram of protein, not per tub (the pain); a lab certificate for every batch (the fear); and “tastes like nothing, mixes with a spoon” (the desire). None of them is clever. All of them are things buyers already said they want, in close to their own words.

Making it hold up

  • Count, don’t just quote. One vivid comment isn’t a theme. The recipe asks for how many comments raised each point, so you can tell a pattern from one loud person.
  • Mark the buyers. Marketers sometimes dismiss Reddit as people who never buy. Quotes that name a brand they used, a price they paid or a product they cancelled answer that, and they’re the ones to put in a deck.
  • Keep the links. Every quote links to its comment, so a client or a colleague can check it.
  • Run it again before each campaign. Prices, scares and fashions change, and the comments move with them.

For a Reddit-only version with a single pain table, see the voice of customer recipe. To find the subreddits first, the free subreddit rules checker shows what each community allows before you post in it.

Questions

What is voice of customer research?

Collecting what customers say about their problem and the products they've tried, in their own words, so marketing and product decisions use their language and their priorities instead of yours. Interviews and surveys are one source; public comments on Reddit, YouTube and TikTok are another, and they're unprompted.

What is the Halo strategy?

A customer research method taught by marketer Sabri Suby: find the main keyword for what you sell, go through forums like Reddit for the most emotionally charged comments, and sort them into pains, fears, hopes and desires before writing any copy.

Aren't Reddit commenters mostly people who never buy?

Some are, which is why the recipe marks quotes from people who say they bought, use, switched from or cancelled something. In the protein powder run below, the most useful quotes came from people naming the brand they used to buy and what they pay now.

How is this different from social listening?

Listening tools alert you when your brand is mentioned. This reads a market's conversations in full, mentions of you or not, to learn what people want before you write. You run it when you're planning copy, not every day.

Do I need a Reddit or YouTube account?

No. Scrollhound reads public posts and comments without logging in to anything, and it never posts or replies. You add it to Claude or ChatGPT as a connector.

Let your AI read the whole conversation.

Try a tool right now, or sign up and get your first 100 reads for $0.

Start for $0 Try a free tool

No credit card · Read-only · Never asks for your social logins